Who Stars in What a Way to Go and Which Husband Does Each Actor Play?

Quick Cast Overview

The 1964 film What a Way to Go! features an ensemble cast led by Shirley MacLaine as Louisa May Foster. Her five husbands are played by some of Hollywood's most iconic leading men: Dick Van Dyke (Edgar Hopper), Paul Newman (Larry Flint), Robert Mitchum (Rod Anderson Jr.), Gene Kelly (Pinky Benson), and Dean Martin (Leonard Crawley). The film is structured as a series of parodies, with each husband representing a different cinematic style.

The Legendary Ensemble of What a Way to Go

Released in 1964, What a Way to Go! stands as a high-water mark for the "super-production" era of 20th Century Fox. The film follows the life of Louisa May Foster, a woman who desires a simple, modest life but finds herself cursed with a strange Midas touch: every man she marries becomes fabulously wealthy and then promptly dies, leaving her with an ever-growing fortune she never wanted.

The star power assembled for this production was nearly unprecedented. By securing five of the industry's most prominent leading men to play supporting roles to Shirley MacLaine, the studio created a marketing juggernaut. According to Wikipedia , the film was a significant box office success, ranking among the top ten highest-grossing films of 1964. This was a crucial victory for 20th Century Fox, which was still reeling from the financial strain of the 1963 production of Cleopatra .

The cast is not merely a list of names; it is a carefully curated group of performers who were each at the height of their cultural influence. From the physical comedy of Dick Van Dyke to the method-acting intensity of Paul Newman and the suave musicality of Gene Kelly, each segment of the film allows these actors to parody the very genres that made them famous. This meta-commentary on Hollywood itself is what makes the cast of What a Way to Go! a subject of enduring fascination for film historians and casual viewers alike.

Quick Reference Guide to the Five Husbands and Their Parody Segments

To understand the cast, one must understand the film's episodic structure. Each marriage is presented as a flashback during Louisa's therapy sessions with her psychiatrist. These segments are filmed in distinct cinematic styles, ranging from silent-era slapstick to lush Technicolor musicals.

Actor Character Cinematic Parody Style Cause of Death
Dick Van Dyke Edgar Hopper Silent Film / Slapstick Physical Exhaustion
Paul Newman Larry Flint French New Wave / Bohemian Automated Painting Machine
Robert Mitchum Rod Anderson Jr. International Melodrama Kicked by a Bull
Gene Kelly Pinky Benson Big Budget Musical Trampled by Fans
Dean Martin Leonard Crawley Standard Romantic Comedy N/A (Survives)
Insider Knowledge: While Robert Cummings is a prominent member of the cast, he is often excluded from the "husband" lists. He plays Dr. Stephanson, the psychiatrist who frames the narrative. His role is essential for the film's structure, acting as the audience's surrogate as Louisa recounts her bizarre history.

Why Shirley MacLaine Was the Perfect Louisa May Foster

Shirley MacLaine’s performance is the glue that holds these wildly different segments together. Interestingly, the role of Louisa May Foster was not originally written for her. The project was initially developed as a vehicle for Marilyn Monroe. Following Monroe's tragic death in 1962, the production was retooled for MacLaine, who brought a different energy to the character.

Where Monroe might have played Louisa as a "blonde bombshell" unaware of her own power, MacLaine portrays her with a grounded, "gamine" quality that makes her desire for a simple life feel sincere. Her ability to pivot from the exaggerated physical comedy required in the Dick Van Dyke segment to the sophisticated glamour of the Robert Mitchum chapter demonstrates why she was widely considered one of the most versatile actresses of the 1960s. According to IMDb , MacLaine's performance is often cited as the emotional anchor that prevents the film from becoming a mere series of disconnected sketches.

MacLaine also had to endure a grueling production schedule that included 72 costume changes, all designed by the legendary Edith Head. Her character's evolution from a simple country girl in a gingham dress to a high-fashion widow draped in millions of dollars worth of jewels is a visual representation of the film's central irony: the more she tries to be poor, the more the world forces her to be rich.

How Dick Van Dyke Parodied the Silent Film Era as Edgar Hopper

The first husband, Edgar Hopper, is played by Dick Van Dyke. At the time of filming, Van Dyke was a household name thanks to The Dick Van Dyke Show . His segment is a brilliant homage to the silent film era, specifically the works of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton. The sequence begins in black and white with a lower frame rate to mimic early cinema, eventually transitioning into color as Edgar’s success grows.

Van Dyke’s background in physical comedy is utilized to its full potential here. He plays a man who owns a tiny, failing general store and wants nothing more than to live a quiet life with Louisa. However, his competitive nature is triggered by Leonard Crawley (Dean Martin), leading him to transform his store into a massive retail empire. The parody highlights the "American Dream" gone wrong, as Edgar becomes so obsessed with efficiency and expansion that he literally works himself to death. His demise from pure exhaustion serves as the first warning to Louisa that her "curse" is real.

Paul Newman as the Bearded Bohemian Larry Flint

Paul Newman’s segment is perhaps the most visually distinct, parodying the French New Wave (Nouvelle Vague) movement. Newman plays Larry Flint, an American expatriate living in Paris who spends his days driving a taxi and his nights creating "art for art's sake." This role allowed Newman to step away from his typical "leading man" persona, sporting a thick beard and adopting a shifting, pseudo-intellectual accent that many viewers find to be a highlight of the film.

The parody includes classic New Wave tropes: jump cuts, philosophical monologues, and subtitles that don't always match the spoken dialogue. Larry’s downfall occurs when he invents a machine that paints based on sound. The machine becomes a sensation, making him millions, but Larry eventually becomes a slave to his own invention. In a darkly comedic twist, the automated painting machines turn on him, leading to his death. Newman’s performance is a sharp critique of the commercialization of art, a theme that remains relevant decades later.

Robert Mitchum and the Lush Melodrama of Rod Anderson Jr.

When Louisa meets Rod Anderson Jr., played by Robert Mitchum, the film shifts into the territory of the "International Jet-Set" melodrama. This segment parodies the high-gloss, big-budget films of the late 50s and early 60s, such as The Carpetbaggers . Mitchum, known for his "tough guy" roles in film noir, plays against type as a refined, ultra-wealthy tycoon who is so busy making money that he has no time for his wife.

The visual style here is one of extreme luxury—private jets, massive estates, and a constant parade of high-fashion outfits. Unlike the previous husbands, Rod is already wealthy when he meets Louisa, but her presence causes his fortune to quadruple. His death is one of the most absurd in the film: while intoxicated, he attempts to milk a bull, thinking it is a cow, and is kicked to death. Mitchum’s deadpan delivery amidst the escalating absurdity of his character's wealth makes this segment a fan favorite on platforms like Letterboxd .

Gene Kelly and the Iconic All-Pink Musical Sequence

The Gene Kelly segment is widely regarded as the most visually iconic part of the movie. Kelly plays Pinky Benson, a small-time shipboard entertainer who performs in a tattered costume. Louisa marries him because she believes he is the one man who will never become successful. However, after she suggests he change his act, he becomes a global superstar.

This chapter parodies the "Big Budget Hollywood Musical." Everything in Pinky’s life becomes a performance, and as his fame grows, his world becomes increasingly pink. The famous "Pink Mansion" sequence features a pink house, pink furniture, pink cars, and even a dog that has been dyed pink. Kelly’s choreography is top-tier, showcasing the grace that made him a legend, even as he parodies the vanity of a star who has lost touch with reality. His death occurs at the premiere of his latest film, where he is literally trampled by his adoring fans—a literal interpretation of being "loved to death."

Dean Martin as the Bookending Suitor Leonard Crawley

Dean Martin plays Leonard Crawley, the wealthiest man in Louisa’s hometown and the catalyst for the entire story. In the beginning, Louisa rejects his advances because he is too focused on money. This rejection sets her on the path to her other marriages. Martin plays the role with his signature "cool" charisma, serving as the standard romantic comedy lead against which all the other parodies are measured.

The film comes full circle when Louisa, now the wealthiest woman in the world, encounters Leonard again. In a significant role reversal, Leonard has lost all his money and is working as a humble farmhand. This final segment provides the resolution to Louisa’s journey, suggesting that happiness is found not in the absence of money, but in the presence of a partner who values simplicity over status. Martin’s performance is understated compared to the other husbands, providing a necessary balance to the film’s more eccentric chapters.

Who Is the Sixth Man in the Cast?

While the five husbands receive the most attention, the cast includes another vital male lead: Robert Cummings . Playing Dr. Stephanson, Cummings provides the narrative framework for the entire movie. As Louisa recounts her story, the doctor becomes increasingly overwhelmed by the sheer impossibility of her life. His reactions—ranging from professional skepticism to genuine bewilderment—mirror the audience's own experience.

Cummings was a veteran of both film and television, and his comedic timing is essential for the "therapy" scenes to work. These scenes allow the film to transition between its various parody styles without feeling disjointed. By the end of the film, even the doctor is not immune to the strange gravity of Louisa’s life, adding a final layer of comedy to the production.

The 72 Costumes of Edith Head and the Film’s Visual Legacy

No discussion of the What a Way to Go! cast is complete without mentioning the contribution of Edith Head . The legendary costume designer was given a massive budget to create a wardrobe for Shirley MacLaine that would reflect the escalating wealth of her husbands. MacLaine has 72 costume changes in the film, a number that remains staggering even by modern Hollywood standards.

The costumes were more than just clothing; they were integral to the parody. In the Paul Newman segment, MacLaine wears bohemian, artsy attire. In the Robert Mitchum segment, she is draped in furs and "widow's weeds" that look like high-fashion runway pieces. The production also famously borrowed $3.5 million worth of actual jewels for MacLaine to wear, requiring a constant security presence on set. This commitment to visual excess was a deliberate choice by director J. Lee Thompson to emphasize the film's themes of greed and artifice.

Behind the Scenes of a 20th Century Fox Super-Production

The production of What a Way to Go! was a strategic move by 20th Century Fox. Following the near-bankruptcy caused by Cleopatra , the studio needed a hit that utilized their contract stars and existing resources. Director J. Lee Thompson, who had recently directed the action-heavy The Guns of Navarone , was an unusual choice for a high-concept comedy, but his disciplined approach helped keep the complex, multi-genre production on track.

One interesting piece of fan-lore involves the film's promotional materials. Many viewers have noted that the original movie posters feature illustrations of the actors that bear very little resemblance to their real-life counterparts. Specifically, the illustrations of Dick Van Dyke and Robert Mitchum are often confused by fans. This discrepancy is frequently discussed in classic film communities as a quirk of 1960s studio marketing, where posters were often commissioned before final casting or costume designs were finalized.

Key Takeaways from the Cast of What a Way to Go!

  • Ensemble Power: The film features a rare gathering of five major leading men: Van Dyke, Newman, Mitchum, Kelly, and Martin.
  • Parody Structure: Each actor represents a specific cinematic style, from Silent Film to French New Wave and Technicolor Musicals.
  • Shirley MacLaine's Versatility: Originally intended for Marilyn Monroe, the lead role became a showcase for MacLaine's comedic and dramatic range.
  • Visual Excess: Costume designer Edith Head created 72 unique outfits, supported by $3.5 million in borrowed jewelry.
  • Narrative Frame: Robert Cummings plays the psychiatrist who anchors the episodic story through therapy sessions.
  • Historical Context: The film was a vital financial success for 20th Century Fox in the post-Cleopatra era.

If you are looking to experience a unique piece of Hollywood history that parodies the industry itself, this film ranks among the top choices for its era.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Cast

Who are the five husbands in the movie What a Way to Go!?

The five husbands are played by Dick Van Dyke (Edgar Hopper), Paul Newman (Larry Flint), Robert Mitchum (Rod Anderson Jr.), Gene Kelly (Pinky Benson), and Dean Martin (Leonard Crawley). Each husband represents a different stage of Louisa May Foster's life and a different style of filmmaking.

Why is the Gene Kelly segment entirely pink?

The "all-pink" aesthetic in the Gene Kelly segment is a parody of Hollywood's obsession with "bigger is better" Technicolor musicals. It represents the peak of Hollywood excess, where even the most mundane objects (and pets) are color-coordinated for the sake of visual spectacle. According to IU Blogs , this sequence is one of the most celebrated examples of production design in 1960s comedy.

Did Paul Newman actually paint the pictures in his segment?

No, the paintings were part of a comedic gag involving "automated painting machines." The machines were designed to create abstract art based on sound, which Larry Flint (Newman) uses to become a wealthy artist. The segment parodies the Bohemian art scene in Paris and the French New Wave cinema movement.

Was Marilyn Monroe supposed to be in the cast?

Yes, the role of Louisa May Foster was originally written specifically for Marilyn Monroe. After her death, the script was revised for Shirley MacLaine. This change shifted the tone of the film from a "blonde bombshell" comedy to a more whimsical, gamine-led anthology.

Is What a Way to Go! considered a musical?

While the film contains musical numbers—most notably the Gene Kelly sequence and a dance routine with Dick Van Dyke—it is primarily classified as a comedy anthology. It uses musical elements to parody the musical genre rather than being a traditional musical itself.

Copyright Disclaimer: All trademarks, copyrighted content, and quoted material referenced in this article belong to their respective owners. Brief excerpts and cast details are used under fair use (17 U.S.C. § 107) for purposes of commentary, criticism, and informational reporting. This article is not affiliated with or endorsed by 20th Century Fox or the estates of the performers mentioned.

© 2026 Film History Insights. All rights reserved.